Dave, you know I love you, and I hear what you are saying, but, on the other hand, at least Phil had the cahones to put it out there. I mean, do you honestly think he is the only contestant that is using Supernova to promote other agendas? For that matter, aren't there members of Supernova that are using Supernova to promote their other projects? I know, I know, that's just me talkin' crazy...and while I'm on the subject of talkin' crazy, Zayra's song choice really touched me last night, she's got moxie!!
love,
jezzi(committed!!)

God Save the Queen.

Well, Jezz, since you put it out there...

Direct quote from Jason Voivod...oh I mean Newsted.

"It's a good chance to really pimp some serious Voivod and also my studio, Chophouse," he said. "The first show airs July 5, and Voivod's new album, Katorz, comes out July 25. So I'll certainly be wearing some Voivod clothing during the weeks leading up to the release of the record and following its release, and I'll be mentioning the band in various appearances."

"Really, you can't buy this kind of publicity," he concluded. "Somewhere between 20 and 40 million people around the globe will watch this show every week. If I got together with the guys in Metallica and we put all our money together to advertise, it still wouldn't come close to what they're spending to plug this show, which is backed by Verizon, Microsoft and Honda."

So, gee, I can imagine the rockers being a bit confused about the whole commitment thing when even SuperWTF can't seem to commmit.

Whatever.

People may be promoting other things, but they aren't talking shit about the band they are in or auditioning for...

It was sweet as hell to hear him do Failure!!!!!!!!!, although he screwed the chorus. Is it just me or do all the singers suck, this year and last. All the same!!!! They all try to be more than they really are or whatever. None of these singers ever stand out as a great frontman... They are all "whats going on right now" with their star and spiderweb tattoos... I doubt this is the best those guys in the band could find.

Dave --- I don't think Phil was talking "shit" about the band, was he? I thought it pertained to one particular riff he had heard and didn't like. So are SN so pansy-assed that they can't take a little criticism? That every musical note they play *might not* be a homerun? Please.

Listen, at the end of the day everyone knows it wasn't going to be Phil to front this band. So why make an issue out of an interview WEEKS old. Man that's just wrong.

I feel that Brooke, Dave, Tommy, Gilby and Jason are free to promote other stuff on the sly. It's their show so to speak. They are not a competitor.

I'M SUPER HAPPY PHIL GOT GUILLOTINED OFF THE SHOW INSTEAD OF ZAYARA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

His performances are wimpy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
and he has no fire down below!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

"People may be promoting other things, but they aren't talking shit about the band they are in or auditioning for..."
BAM BAM! The excessive complaining about this show here and elsewhere is getting ridiculous. If people REALLY get that bent on the show, I'm pretty sure there's no law that says they have to watch it. Jesus, lighten up people, it's a TV show about a Rock and Roll band auditioning for a singer. It ain't politics or international diplomacy.

I didn't catch the show last year, but overall I am impressed with the quality of the singers.

I was a little surprised that Phil went home instead of Zayra, but personally I can only see 4 possible, legit winners. And they weren't in the bottom 3 last night. It was only a matter of time before Phil went home anyway. So why not reward the singers that are at least really givin' it?

Props on Phil's song choice last night though, if not his shit-talking afterwards.

Oh yeah Dave, thanx for Philling in the Blanks.
Funny, because I viewed Phil as shooting blanks musically!!! At least in the context of fronting RS:SN.

Though even without this info, I would have sent him home just on his performances alone!!!

Yoo hoo one less performer I don't enjoy gone!!!

just from the 30 seconds or so when gilby was playing the music, at the mansion one could tell Phil wasn't digging it the way some others were.

I have seen Phil's band Lennex, they sound nothing like what he's been singing on the show with the exception of the failure song.
He wasn't a good fit and wasn't going to win the gig. I was ,however, hoping he would last a little longer than some of the other dreadful male fronts on the show, Ryan and Toby bring nothing unique to the table yet somehow they escape.

I agree with Shoe, it must be kind of hard to give it your all when you know this is a one off side project for the established members who are not shy about saying so.

Sorry Dave - Phil brings something actually heavy that we have never heard before and Zay redoes her REM performance with a diff song but the same bad vocals and eyelash batting - and you say PHIL didn't change it up? Tsk Tsk.

I can see how what Phil did was inexcusable and why he got cut - but come on.

Dave, I love how much you are interacting with our comments today.

As for Phil, whether he was really commited to being in the band or not, he is totally wrong for Supernova.

Actually, I was really shocked and disappointed at the selection of contestants. I thought most of them would be like Lukas or Dilana, not like American Idol contestants. I only watch for you Dave, as well as Lukas and Dilana.

BTW, if you're still hanging around checking out our comments, I have to ask you once more: Where did you get that awesome black shirt with the red crosses? Do I have to make a critical remark about your shirt to get an answer? Ha Ha

*cringes for Phil*

Ouch! That was below the belt dude, even from YOU...lol.

Poor Phil.

On the otherhand, do they have chiropracters to TIGHTEN you up instead of loosen you up? If so, Phil needs to see one of THEM.

Peace.

Don't forget,these people are auditioning for a band whose music they haven't even heard yet,apart from the previous bands they've been in,whose to say more of the "contestants" won't dig it.

Can't wait for The Contender

^^ my last comment was directed at "the person" who wrote about Phil shooting "musical blanks." Yow.

Peace.

Ok, with that kind statement, not being stoked by Supernovas music, hell yeh they should send him home...I still think Zayra sucked..WTF do the guys see in her????? I would like to hear some different music, repeats of last year. Dilana is the best of all, Storm was really hot this week.
Your in my dreams...

I am just pleased to hear Failure on primetime!

"I'm not stoked about the music Supernova's popping out."

I'm not sure how Phil could say something like that and (anyone) expect that he stick around another week.

Sure everyone is there for a variety of reasons, there's nothing to apologize for or hide in that regard. Phil stupidly crossed the line in a big way which is much worse than giving another lame or unsuitable performance.

Vibes,
K

I don't know if I would consider that talking shit about SN, but expressing uncertainty about what the music would be like. I get where SN are coming from, since it has been printed, but the article was from before the show aired and before the contestants had a really clear idea what the SN sound was going to be like. Considering that the sounds of the 3 bands in which SN were members are vastly different and hit their peak popularity a few years ago, Phil may have had a different idea of where the music of SN was going. I thought he changed his tune on his blog once he heard the new direction. I do think Phil made a big mistake in never saying that it wasn't just about wanting to win, but wanting to be a member of Supernova.

I am a bit perturbed that we are helping to select a person for a band that seems ultimately destined for only one album and tour rather than something a bit more lasting though. I am more annoyed that Jason Newsted (and I luuuurve Jason Newsted) has made it clear that this is just to promote Voivod, and will ultimately have a divided focus. What I liked about last year was that JD was going into something with longterm potential and that INXS didn't have another visible agenda.

I guess I find it disappointing that Phil got cut for having divided loyalites, when it also seems to be happening within SN. And more disappointing to me is that they consider that talking shit, but they have yet to get rid of snarky little Jill or Zayra who have thrown out insults directly to them. As a matter of fact, is it just me or are more of the rockers butting heads with SN?

I don't think Phil would have ultimately won the thing, but I would much rather see them get rid of people who are disrespectful and insulting, than someone who was unsure before walking in the door. But I suppose, if SN is that distraught about it, then they probably shouldn't have him around.

phil deserved it. he looks half dead out there. i think i'm in love with dilana and dare i say it, she reminds me of joplin. oh yeah, it's true.

Phil didn't do it for me either. Zayra is only a matter of time before she goes and I've said before she should have been the first. So far...they are dropping off as I expected. Things can change dramatically in the next few weeks when the pressure starts to get to them.
It will be interesting to see how it plays out.

i'm actually glad he's gone. i found him boring and typical! but wtf, why is zayra still there???? it's gotta be for ratings :D

To all the ignorant out there: Voivod isn't a touring band anymore. Piggy died last August. So Voivod had to finish the "Katorz" album with Piggy's demo guitar tracks, recorded on his laptop.

The new album is a tribute to their fallen friend.

And with a backlog of Piggy riffs + ideas archived on that computer, Voivod will release one more new album in 2007.

But Voivod is essentially "on hiatus" now, if not completely done with, as a band. So Jason Newsted has all the time in the world to devote to Super Nova.

His attention is not divided.

Dave,

I don't know if this has been asked before and/or answered. But I love the house band!! Who are these guys and do they have their own band(s)or what? They are bad ass in my opinion!!

Any info. appreciated from anyone ;)

Hasn't Phil ever heard of the INTERNET to promote his band?
Sheeesh why waste everyone's time?

Hmmmm hmmmm...

Was I the only one that saw the Motley Crue/Aerosmith performance ads?
During SuperNova intermission?
http://www.newyorkticketsonline.com/ResultsEvent.aspx?event=Aerosmith%20%26%20Motley%20Crue

Or did anyone else see them?

On another note, I'm not going to bust the 3 guys balls about who they choose to send home. After all it's their party and they can send home who they want to!

Dave, I do respect you, not so much Super BS Nova!
and this show has completely blown itself out of the water (imo). Come on, if Jason Newsted can promote his band on Rockstar and talk about them on interviews then you mean to tell me that none of the other rockers are allowed to self prompt? what a bunch of BS! since we're on the subject, almost everyone of those guys on that stage singing comes from another band. Not that I am or was a fan of Phil, but this show is really starting to smell. Talk about a double standard!

Oh, and Gilby with Jill...so what you guys are showing is, that its fine for a male TLee, we make passes on national Television to Storm, but Gawd forbid if some chicky rubs and grinds herself onto one of you guy in the heat of the moment of singing. Ah, another double standard!

Sorry Dave, but that just ALL stinks!

I guess I just felt a little bad for Phil because it seemed like the guys of Supernova had their minds already made up. When the rockers are put in the bottom 3, they are performing to save themselves. Chris did his best performance and was sent packing that same night...same thing happend to Phil. I understand it's part of the show, but why would these rockers have to even perform when the band knows who's gonna be sent home before they even perform? I would venture to say that every contestant is there for their own exposure. It's an opportunity for them to get in the spotlight. Phil probably wasn't going to make it till the end, but I do think that he left too early. Lots of people on the message boards are talking about boycotting this show or voting as many times as they can for Zayra so the band gets stuck with her. Is this really the kind of loyalty and show that this band wants to rely on? They talk about questioning Phil's commitment, they should focus on their fan's commitment to them as well. I love the show, but honestly, it's becoming a joke to many.

Yeah, while I gave Phil a big fucking thumbs up on choosing Failure as his 'get out of jail' song, talking smack like that pretty much sums up what (to me) is the undercurrent of this entire season... an entire group that is very out of their element, unable to adapt and not having the wit or intell to do their research before going into the mix.

Out of the entire bunch, Dillana is the only one that you get the feel that she knows why she is there and she's on a fucking mission to make it happen and knows exactly what it will take.

The real question... is her sound right for the band?

But damn, if this is the 'best unsigned singers' the world has to offer that CBS could find, I obviously need to go back into A & R...

BTW... I really like Zayra.
She has a cool spirit.
I dig her style.
She's got moxie, in spades.

But apparently, a lot of you hate her with a passion.

Ah, in the end, who cares?
It's just music.
And it's just someone's opinion.

After all, some people think Perry Farrell sounds like an annoying high-pitched insect (like Geddy Lee).

But to me, Perry was one of the greatest vocalists of all time.

You know what they say about opinions + assholes: that it feels good to stick your finger in them...

INXS was a well established famous band years before RockStar
SuperNova has been manufactured specifically for this season of RockStar.
Personally,i respect Newstead for his honesty..at least he is telling it like it is,his reasons for doing it,all of them are there to promote themselves...there is that chance the music might actually be good.

Commitment or no commitment, Phil was SO not the one for the job. His performance last night was by far his best, IMO, but someone had to go.

I liked the diversity of the song choices last night - and in all the elimination shows so far. It's cool to see the contestants in their true element on Wed. nights, doing their favorite songs, fighting for their lives, so to speak. The pressure really seems to bring out the best in them.

If only they could have that do-or-die attitude all the time...

Have a wonderful day, everyone. For those going to the NYC show, have a great time!

To Peebs: Phil's band lennex is on the web.
http://www.lennex.com
their web site is actually pretty cool, they're with I-tunes & cd baby. they're doing the net...

posting twice in one day for me, yikes. Phil is a homie of sorts, his band plays in my area; so a lot of us are happy to have him back but wished he'd last a little longer, maryland represent ! :) c'est la vie !

Face it. Phil had a weird neck wobble and Zayra has a nice ass which would you rather watch for another week if you're one of the Supernova guys? ......Exactly!

See ya Phil! If there is a god Jill will go next. But really... does anyone really expect Hootie...I mean Josh to hang around much longer?

Paul Mirkovich's RockStar SuperNova blog
http://rockstar2006paul.spaces.msn.com/
+ http://www.paulmirkovich.com/

Nate Morton's RockStar SuperNova blog
http://rockstar2006nate.spaces.msn.com/
+ http://www.natemorton.com/

Jim McGorman
http://jimmcgorman.com/

Hey DNKicksAss...

(Isn't it suppose to be DNLikesFineAss - lol...)

here's some links for ya...

aahhhh the wonders of G-O-O-G-L-E and cut'n'paste...

Rafael Moreira
http://www.rafaelmoreira.com/

Sasha Krivtsov
his art website http://www.desaart.com/bio.html
He's a very good artist!!!
http://www.rockstargohome.com/rock-star-inxs-sasha-krivtsov-bass.php

Their MSN RockStar SuperNova page at large
http://rockstar.msn.com/show/houseband

Now that my headcold is almost gone...
I'd love some red wine Sangria!!!

To those of you dissing Jason for promoting his other projects...I say the same thing to you that Dave said to Patrice when she got lippy: Jason Newsted already has a job, and he's not auditioning. This television show is not HIS once in a lifetime opportunity to play with world-famous musicians and become famous himself. Hello, he's done that, several times over, even. This is a (fun?) project for him. These contestants, on the other hand, have been given an amazing opportunity here, and talking shit about the very band who is giving you that golden chance is straight up retarded. They need to prove themselves; Jason doesn't.

Poor Phil the huge rockstar was going to lower himself to play in a band he didn't even like with little nobody guys like these? Riiiiiiight. Buh-bye, emo douche.

True that, Dave!!! Man, you answered so fast, it was like having a real time convo with ya!

I remember what Neil wrote about you in DTTAH...do NOT get into an argument with Dave!! My mom used to tell me, don't go into a battle of wits unarmed..

But, I'm also glad to see I wasn't the only one thinking that...
love!!!
jezzi(back to international diplomacy and censorship)

Bet this has been asked before....I'm sure this is all done in the edit process...how does the band know the tune of each bottom 3 performer on the spot. Does every competitor submit "survival" songs in advance?

I am not dissing Jason, but I am disappointed that SN doesn't seem to be the long-term opportunity it seemed to be when the season started. Jason just happens to have expressed it to the press. If his Voivod committment is only one more album, as someone else mentioned earlier, then great, but there are concerns that Tommy has his loyalties to Motley Crue as well. Last season, INXS seemed like a real opportunity because they were genuinely looking for someone to be the new lead singer in the band for years to come. This season seems more experimental and uncertain from the get go and more reality tv than the authentic audition it was supposed to be. Whatever though, I still adore Dave and SN, and most of the rockers, but I empathize with Phil.

Dave - Did he make those statements before or after the hatchet last night?

Think about this: It does kind of suck for us viewers if he is being booted off because of statements he made outside of the context of the show. If Supernova is going to use other criteria than the performances or what goes on in the mansion, then please show it during the context of the show. Otherwise, the credibility of the show is jeapordized.

Just my 2 cents.

SuperNova did the right thing! I support their decision. Yes, the other rockers are also there to promote themselves. And other are there to get this gig.

But you DO NOT bad mouth your potential future band. That's just idiotic. So, see you around Booblehead! Have a nice life.

Now as for Jason promoting Voivod. Why not? They are not going out on tour, they have a new cd coming out. Is Jason so one dimensional that he can't support Voivod and be in SuperNova also? I'm sure he has the ability to do both. You cannot compare what Jason is doing to what Phil did. Jason did not dis his own band to the press.

For those that go to the Rockstar site on MSN, have you noticed that Phil's exit video was there and now it's not. This would be the video where he explains his comments in the newspaper article. Which now seem very out of context since none of that was used on the elimination show last night. Weird.

I thought Phil sucked ass musically for the most part, so I was ready for him to go home.

I'll admit that I was a bit surprised last night that he was sent home before Zayara, but after learning about his comments to the newspaper, I can understand that. (I do agree with LA that it would have been nice for the editors to have shown us a little of that exchange for context, but hey, it's not my show.) But I knew that Phil was, in Tim's words, "just not roight" for Supernova. If he hadn't gone home this week, it would have been next week.

Anyway, that's my two cents, not that it really matters. Also, I just wanted to let you know that I've been a huge fan of "Rock Star" since the first episode of last season. Thanks for helping bring it back this summer. You rawk.

Krazy, in response to your comment about a double standard, I want to share my take on the interaction between Gilby and Jill:

I was very impressed that Gilby told Jill that women shouldn't lower themselves by simulating sex on stage. He said it looks cheap, and at times it does. I believe that comment shows Gilby respects women and doesn't respond to them based on their physical attributes. I don't think it was a double standard, it was just his point of view. When you think about it, a man respecting women is amazing in the world of rockstars!

Hey,

I do believe people are missing the point of this show. Yes there is a competition of 16 rockers vying to front Supernova but the real competition in my opion is selling supernova to us the fans. The fact that a contestant didn't like a riff written by the band and went public saying so and the result was him getting released from the competetion I can understand why the band would feel that way and not wanting any of their contestance dissing their work but as a potential paying costumer of Supernova I have a far less problem with a contestant not liking a riff than I have with a supernova guy promoting other things or openingly saying they are using the show to promote other work. I am far more concerned that I am wasiting my time following a band that may never fly because it is not even the most important thing to the people envolved. I keep reading posts of people defending the fact that they already have a job well that is a bunch of bull shit because the show they are selling to us the viewer is ROCKSTAR SUPERNOVA not rockstar Voivod. I am much for offended when I read what Jason said in a article released by MTV saying somthing along the lines of all the money in metallica couldn't promote his Voivod stuff like this show was going to do for him and that he is going to use the show to promote their(voivod) stuff bye wearing t shirts and dropping thier name from time to time (Which has happened in ever show thus far)Jason actually wore a Voivod shirt when he did his song with Phil. I would feel a whole lot better being that I am a potential supernova fan that they announced that Jason has decided to make Voivod his number one project and that the band felt like they needed someone who was going to be in it for the long haul and that they would be announcing a new bassist in the new future So I can continue to become a hard core supernova fan and I can waist all my hard earn money on concert tickets,CD's, DVD's for a band that is actually going to exist beyond the only booked gig the band has and that is the new years eve gig in Las Vegas.

There are more than a few who suck ass. Zayra or whatever the hell her name is has got to go - she doesn't even sing on key most of the time. Jill is just annoying as hell and looks like she should be trying to sell you make up or some kind of beauty cream behind the counter at a department store. Then there is pretty boy Josh -- get his ass out of there. He needs to be singing at a stock show or something but not for SuperNova. After that, I can deal with the rest of them until the end, but those 3 are just sucking the life out of me to watch.

[Disclaimer: So this started as a comment on the entry, but turned into a bit of a rant - not directed at anyone in particular.]

From the first episode of this season, it was obvious to me that there were only a handful (if that) of contestants that could front Supernova. That being said, I don't much mind what order the other contestants get kicked off in. Granted, when I'm watching a performance from someone that I can't stand (i.e. Josh or Zayra), it makes me wish that they were already gone. However, in the grand scheme of things, I do get over it. I do have a life apart from this show, and hey, it's not my band anyway.

Even before you said anything, Dave, I did remark that Zayra could be a Bjork-ish type performer. In similar fashion, I do think that every contestant on the show has talent. The show isn't just about finding talent though, it's about finding the right fit for a band that's already working together.

Let's also keep in mind that it is a reality tv show. There have to be upsets or no one will watch it. TV can suck that way, but that's why I don't watch much of it. I decided to watch Rock Star this season, and knew what I was getting myself into. You suck it up and deal with it. Of course, you could always not watch it - no one is forcing you to.

If someone is serious about wanting a job, he or she doesn't trash-talk the establishment in a plublic way before going into the interview. The media can be evil, so I don't know whether or not that's exactly what Phil did. But hey, he wasn't going to win anyway (and that doesn't make him talentless, he just doesn't fit.)

\m/

"Bet this has been asked before....I'm sure this is all done in the edit process...how does the band know the tune of each bottom 3 performer on the spot. Does every competitor submit "survival" songs in advance?"
I came across an article that interviewed a house band member and they said that all of them choose and practice a "bottom 3 song" just in case they're chosen.

IMHO, this project is part experiment for the 3 as well. And maybe like any other band that forms they will only put out 1 cd and do one world tour.
That's life. Take it while it's there or miss out.

As for voting, I'd really like to know how strong the votes count. I mean how strong can they really count when we can vote 1million times at the same computer. I mean if the bottom 3 that are chosen by audience voters aren't the same bottom 3 ones that the 3 choose, how goes it?

I liked how SRL'SIndieArtistOfTheMonth is set up that you can vote once from the same computer (at least mine was that way).

How right you are! I am not a fan of Zayra, and would like to see her go home, but in addition to a lack of commitment, I personally thought Phil's performance last night sucked anyway. At least the others are genuinely making an effort, like you said.

I so agree with what you said Jacqui about there only being a few that could actually front SN. Also, wholeheartedly agree with the comment about Zayara being Bjork-ish. My husband and I actually said that she could be a Cranberry. Anuyways, you are right about TV having to have those moments of upsets & disgust in order to keep people watching. Too bad however for those of us that have to sit through one of those agaonizing (often embarassing) performances. Dave, by the way you are looking HOT as usual and I love your honesty in the interaction that you have with the rockers. If they can't take it from you then they are in the wrong biz -- there are going to be people all over everything they do if they make it in that world. Much Love

I have to ask this:

Are Storm's breast real?

(and I'm sure I'm not the only one who's wondering about that!)

Zayra's performance tonight was... okay, maybe even good. the best I've seen from here.

And give the encore to Lucas already!

hey dave
i am a huge fan or yours and love you and the guys but yea i know what you mean but i am still really disappointed w/ phill leaving. like if u ask my friends thats all i talk about. and i read your explination for getting him kicked off but i guess you could actually say im mad about it. i dunno im just pretty pissed. phil wasnt even my favorite and im still pissed off.
i heard that the producers and everyone on that show already knew who won and its fake and i didnt believe it until now because phil leaving just doesnt seem believable.
i really hope next week you guys can get me believing that its not all a fake. because up until phile leaving it used 2 b my favorite show.

I think it is ok to promote other bands/ projects because it allows for more expsoure of their talent. We can check them out singing the songs they like- just like one would present a resume for a regular job and the 'empolyer' (in our case the buying public) can check refences so to speak. However, it was the comments he had made about not being interested in fronting SN that I think was the problem. Why have some one who does not want to be there.

Having said that, I do not see why they did not do a double elimination, Phil and Zayra. Yes she may try something new each week, takes feedback well and takes it seriously but she is not right for the band and has been in the bottom 3 the most. Dave you said it yourself that she needs to pack her bags and go so I am a little confused as to why your now defending her? The more I watch her performances the more I dislike what she is presenting. I don't know, maybe she just sounds bad on TV.

Hey Dave--A number of folks have noticed that the Rocker's blogs have been edited in the last 24 hours. Specifically, Lukas blog has been edited to remove complaints about how he has been edited (..."I’ve heard I’m being portrayed as a drunk and that sucks… You will know the real me by listening to my voice and looking into my eyes. This is only Hollywood not the real world....) on the show. Also deleted was what may or may not have been a shot at the Supernova guys' commitment to the project after attending the Voivod release party ("...How many bands do these boy’s have? But whatever that’s their business.) .

Did MPB really think we wouldn't notice that the blogs had been edited? There are a lot of folks out there that like to live on the grassy knoll while dreaming up conspiracy theories. Edits like these only help the conspiracy theorists and delegitimize the show.

It seems like there is a lot of backtracking today in light of last night's ouster of Phil.
Just deleting some one's words from a blog doesn't make them vanish. Anything can live on in cyberspace by virtue of a copy and paste command. And so it has in this case.

dave i agree whole heartedly - i got your babe !

Kim is right--- they changed the Lucas blog post for July 24.
http://rockstar2006lukas.spaces.msn.com/

The edits make him sound chipper + happy, whereas his original post was kind of pissy.

Dave Navarro is reading all of our rants + speculation... and he's laughing all the way to the bank! As an executive producer, Dave has a vested interest in controversy + ratings.

Let's make him happy!

oh but i do have to say .... Hollywood - is the real world - we revole around it look to it for entertainment ...etc.... Hollywood is the real world folks - love ya all -

SuperNova doesn't need anyone micro-managing their moves. It's their show.

Also, how does one know who edited the blogs?
The show or themself?

And no matter what happens I'm following what Dilana does music wise afterwards.

As well as Patrice in her solo career, where she fares much better ever than fronting SuperNova which she ain't cut out for.

I just thought it was lame to throw an old article from July 7th at Phil AFTER he had already gotten the hatchet. Especially when he was just raving in his blog about how excited he was about the possibility of playing with them after he heard the songs.

Linda, thanks for the reply. I believe that perhaps Gilby meant well, however TLee is consistently making (imho) plays for a few of the ladies on up that stage with his comments. If TLee can do that and get away with it, than imho so can Jill. What I saw was a woman simply getting a bit carried away with the bump and grind, nothing more. What I (imho) felt that Gilby did, was to make a big deal out of nothing. I see it as a "boys club only" comment. If the guys can dish it out, then I'm sorry but they have to be able to take it.

Wow, I can't believe I posted twice in 1 day! lol!

I have to say I wasnt all that thrilled with Phil's peformance either. He's just not a good fit for the band.

Rock Star contestant questions Supernova band members' "commitment," first single
July 26, 2006
by Andy Dehnart

Jenny Galt, a contestant on Rock Star: Supernova who was eliminated from the competition, is criticizing both the band’s first single and the commitment to the new band’s long-term success.

“Tommy Lee’s got Motley Crue and Jason Newsted’s very passionate about (Canadian metal band) Voivod, there are a lot of questions as to whether this band is going to really take off. That’s up in the air,� she said. “And then, how much commitment do the actual members of Supernova have? There was a lot of chit-chat in the (Rock Star) mansion about that.�

She also says the contestants in the house aren’t thrilled with the band’s first single. “A lot of people in the group are skeptical about what kind of music they are playing. (Supernova) say they want to do something fresh and new, but then the first track we got to hear, a lot of people were just like, ‘Eww, I’m not sure if I like this,’� she said. “It sounded just like that same old, boys’ rock ‘n’ roll kind of glam thing they said they weren’t going to be doing. It was a bit surprising.�

I'm okay with all controversy this last installment has stirred up. I just watch the show to get my "Dave Fix", anyway. I would buy a SN CD if they pick the right singer (Dilana or Toby), though. Keep it comin', babe! You always have the perfect comments for the rockers - honest and sincere. Thanks for the entertainment!

Hey Dave - check out my blog above - some comments on your show, etc. if you care to comment on them??? P.S. Love your show !!!

Ok, Ok!

Let's face it...most TV just plain SUCKS! Especially the reality shows. But, Rockstar is the best thing on TV and for anyone wanting to boycott it...go ahead. There are plenty of us who love Rock n Roll and will not be tuning out. Who cares how long the band is together? Does this really matter? 1 year sounds great. All I know is that for me, I couldn't wait to find out what band would be auditioning singers for season two this summer and I have not been disappointed. Are people really getting this pissed? Relax, enjoy the music. Yeah, some rockers are not up to the gig, but that's why we're watching...

I have enjoyed Dave & Gilby's comments more than most of the performances. You gotta love it. TESTIFY!!

Anyway, already looking forward to season 3, so to all you Rockstar nay-sayers --

Keep on Rockin' in the FREE world...

Let you tell it Daddio!!!

Kisses~

"Im not a blogger, rock fan hyper, or musical genius. I am a lover of good music of all types. Im a little older than most of the posters on all of the message boards and maybe a little out of touch with todays rock. But, I am astute enough to know one thing for sure. Supernova being made up of 3 people closer to my age than most of you seems to be way out of touch with their market and potential listening audience. And they don't come close to say Led Zepplin, The Who, The Stones etc. etc. etc.

First of all, when these contestants auditioned, they were under the impression that they would be singing contemporary music of today. Not a bunch of songs that are over 30 years old. How can anyone get a feel for the oldies and go up on stage and belt it out like its todays smash hits. Big mistake by supernova. The viewing audience is obviously less than happy. And, I dont care what Brooke says, it has hurt the shows ratings.

Another point! I have listened to all of the available new tracks for the band. Im not feeling it. And neither do the contestants. Sure, Storm and a couple others are saying yea, this is real classic, beer drinkin rock & roll. When all the cameras were packed up and the contestants were left alone, the true feelings came out and they all discussed how they didnt like the music. Go to Jennys myspace and ask her for the truth. Supernova needs to go back to the drawing board and write music that they can sell. All this TV show hype looks good now, but when the dust settles will they have any songs America wants to buy. I dont think so!

This brings me to the 3 points of writing this entry. Integrity, honesty and bad business. Phil Ritchie made a mistake by telling a reporter that his primary purpose for being on the show was to promote his band. There are 11 other people that are there for the exact same reason. Only 1 of them will be able to alter his or her true motive. Phil made a bad business decision by telling the truth. He cant help it. He is the most honest person I know on the planet And, I assure you he has more integrity in his little finger than the 4 rich guys sitting up there passing judgment. I think that the voting is bullshit and bogus. If Phil made it to the bottom 3 this week Ill eat my hat. Why dont they publish the results? So they can manipulate the show and choose the bottom 3 to suit their politcal and rating agenda. If Im wrong, please Supernova, let an independent auditor post the true results each week Yea right!

Phil is gone and it pisses me off. They didnt kick him off for poor vocal ability or even the Dirty Phil Bobble. He was dumped because these 3 musical geniuses cant stand the truth about their aging inability to produce good music. They could have confronted Phil off-camera to find out his true intentions. Sure, they may have been great at one time but, guess what fellas.times up!

If anyone out there doesnt believe Phil wanted to front Supernova your wrong. I personally think he is better off. I just wanted him to stay longer for the exposure because thats just plain good business. For those of you that kept writing hurtful comments about Phils singing ability. Go fuck yourself! You obviously have a limited capacity for recognizing true vocal talent. Of course, most intelligent people here know your true agendas.

For those of you that are interested. You can download most of Phils band songs. Just google Lennex. And BTW, Lennex has 3 record companies looking to sign them. All of that was put on hold for the show. Now, they will have to wait until their legal obligation not to sign for a certain time period runs out. Dont worry, you havent seen or heard the last of Phil Ritchie and Lennex. Their just getting started.

Am I spouting sour grapes? Maybe! All I tell you is that Im Damned proud of my son. I told him when he left that he was already a winner. And I stick by it today. As for the remaining 11 contestants. Good luck, you folks are the best of the best and Im proud of every one of you also. Be yourselves. After all, thats what got you there in the first place."

Thanks for your time. Charlie Ritchie Phils Dad

Favorite Quote of the Day!:

"Dave Navarro is reading all of our rants + speculation... and he's laughing all the way to the bank! As an executive producer, Dave has a vested interest in controversy + ratings.

Let's make him happy!"

hahahahhahahahahahahahahhahahaha!! My thoughts EXACTLY!!!

But Dave, are you REALLY happy? I mean, WHAT would make you REALLY happy?? Come on, you can tell us!! *wink* *wink*

*woof woof* "sit Fido"!!

p.s. Dave, are you saving up money to buy a small island? Small country??

Phil's dad wrote, "Go to Jennys myspace and ask her for the truth."

Well, here is the only MySpace account I could find her Jenny Galt
http://www.myspace.com/jennygaltshawca

She last logged on July 21.
___
I found a different link for a Jenny Galt myspace site, which I got from Rock Star Go Home (which is a site sanctioned by Mark Burnett and the executive producers of Rockstar: Supernova).

Here's her exit interview with Rex:
http://www.rockstargohome.com/jenny-galt-rock-star-supernova-interview.php

But the link at the end of that interview doesn't work: "Invalid Friend ID. This user has either cancelled their membership, or their account has been deleted."

See for yourself:
http://www.myspace.com/jennygalt

At first I was suspcicious that it was because of legal pressure from Rockstar: Supernova. Yeah, wanting to believe conspiracy shit. Like, "They pressured her to shut her site down, because she was talking shit about the show."

But who knows?

Many people do have more than one MySpace account.
Or maybe it was a misprint in the article.

Dave, I get the feeling you're launching a massive war-campaign to REDEFINE, RE-TOOL, and RE-DESIGN the world of HARD ROCK 'n ROLL to better suit the needs of hard rock fans everywhere, by taking FULL ADVANTAGE of every available means of ELECTRONIC MEDIA (especially those on the computer) to PUSH your personal agenda ENVELOPE as far as it can possibly go up under the closed heavy wooden door of yesteryear's best rock 'n roll???

Am I right? huh? huh? Did I hit the nail on the head?? What do I win?????

*runs around excited and happy as a little girl*

:) :) :)

asp(and no, not the stinging insect)

(hehe)

Jenny Galt did used to have a MySpace site at:
http://www.myspace.com/jennygalt

Here is Google cache, from April 2006
http://72.14.209.104/search?q=cache:jtVSg0AWyFgJ:profile.myspace.com/index.cfm%3Ffuseaction%3Duser.viewprofile%26friendID%3D25225131

But that MySpace account is no longer active. Hmm... I wonder why (and when) she canceled that account? We'll never know.

Here is Jenny Galt's other MySpace account, active as of Thursday, July 27, 8:32 EST.
http://www.myspace.com/jennygaltshawca

If that one goes down, too, then we'll know that they're putting the screws to Jenny Galt to remain silent.

You know, here is the deal.

Last year, with INXS, you had a band that knew what they wanted. They made fairly consistent comments and gave consistent direction, pointing out where they wanted to be, and what they expected. I imagine this would be true of any experience band in the show.

Supernova is NOT an experienced band, despite be experienced players. They are still a new band, and near as I can tell they have no idea what they want. The 3 of them are very inconsistent what they say from week to week, telling one person one thing and another person another. There is no real direction towards a goal that I can see; they have no idea what they want. Or at the very least, they have 3 different ideas as to what they want.

They want you to 'crush it', then offer up Time After Time - an awesome song, but you can't crush it. They want to be fresh and new, and yet their music so far sounds like Clash Lite. They say, "have you even ever seen our bands?" and yet, they arent' playing that kind of music, so why the heck should that be even relevent?

They go after Jill and drool after storm. Hell, I don't blame them for that. But don't give me the crap that it's because it's been 'done' and it's played, not when you pop wood because storm does a Carmen booty shake. Be honest, it's because Jill can't do sexy, she sucks at it. By the end of that show, Jill looked about as confused as you can get, and while I personally cannot stand her, I don't blame her one bit.

These guys have no real idea what they want at all. Not as a band.

Dave, you've been consistent, and downright harsh, but for the right reasons. Perhaps that's just experience at doing the show before, but you don't throw them curve balls every week. I wish supernova would show that - INXS sure did, and I think you'd get the same if it were Queen, Rolling Stones, or hell, Devo or some shit.

I love the show, and I love the players, but supernova really needs to go back and watch the comments they've made over the course of the show so far, and figure out what it is they really want.

hey ! ok phil was going to go eventually, just like dana, ryan, jill, josh, etc are going to go eventually but, dude, ZAYRA CAN'T SING !!!!
The top four people that could even think of fronting this band are Dilana, Storm, Lucas or Toby.
Later !

I would politely and in a respectful tone remind you Mr. Richie that the band doesn't vote contestants into the bottom 3-the callers, the viewing public, these are the people that actually pick the bottom 3.
"I just wanted him to stay longer for the exposure because thats just plain good business."
That kind of proves the point that was made by Dave. Sure, Marty Casey and his band are still riding a wave of popularity that didn't exist before the show, but Marty didn't say that the band wasn't popping out his kind of music either. Great bands gain exposure by writing great music and having exceptionally talented musicians perform that music, not by appearing on TV under the guise of actually wanting to be in a different band. If your son is super talented, great, let him put out some great tunes, I hope the signing thing goes well, and I hope we can hear some of it. No one wished your Son ill will. As for the contestants being able to sing contemporary vs. modern music, that's not really a valid point. A great singer can sing from ANY era, not just from their own.
I'm not Dave's keeper, he's a big boy all his own, nor do I speak for anyone other than myself, however, one would certainly have to ask if you were to look at the situation from an objective standpoint, would you still be posting here? Probably not. Submitted respectfully.

Dave, Dave, Dave
Come off it with your holy then thou...but Oh excuse me YOU have a job already...he he Ok dave. NO I am not a hater, but we all know who is going to be picked, so let the others show what they've got. That is the entertainment business. And by the way Dave, I think you should be taking care of business at home, rather then looking for rock stars. Don't blow a good thing when you got it already at home.

Much Love at you Dave ....good luck

Russ

Charlie Ritchie Phils Dad,

I read your post because I was interested in what you had to say. You admit that you are bias as most parents think that their children are the best. You want to protect and stand up for him and I get that. I am sure his band is good but he was not right for SN. As far as resorting to cheap shots against the show, Dave and SN and those involved tells me that you do not believe his talent is strong enough to with stand some criticism. You also said that " I think that the voting is bullshit and bogus.", though I disagree with you, whether or not the 'manipulated votes' put him in the bottom three; at the end of the day it is still SN choice.

"Am I spouting sour grapes? Maybe! All I tell you is that Im Damned proud of my son. I told him when he left that he was already a winner"

Hey Phil's Dad, isn't that what parents are SUPPOSED to say to their kids even when they came in last?

And to John who posted the link to Phil's band, you do realize you are posting on a blog to a man who completely USES the internet for the start of his new band, The Panic Channel. From telling his minons about the new project, the songs available on My Space, to the people on the messageboard who spread the word around other messageboards they post on to gathering up new fans and the pre-CD tour. Completely used the www to push, promote and get more fans by using a homegrown street team.
IF Phil was smart, he could do the same instead of wasting the time of the other contestants, Tommy, Jason and Gilby. And of course Dave ;-)

I'm new here so I won't take liberties (yet:)

I have to agree with Dave on this one and it turn with SN. Regardless of what perceived 'commitment' Gilby, TL, and Jason have to SuperNova there is no way they would keep Phil around after sayin he's 'not stoked' about their music. He chose to voice his opinion in public and SN showed him the door. End of story.

I admire Phil's dad for his post he obviously loves his son very much. Phil is lucky to have him in his corner.

to alien sour puss...

not to rain on your parade but an asp is a poisonous snake not a
stinging insect.

Go Lukas! (fellow Canuck) drink all the free beer you can. Gotta beat the heat don't ya know.

peace y'all

phil sucks!

What's with people wanting to micro-manage and thoroughly watch every move of SuperNovas.

IT'S THEIR SHOW and will BE THEIR BAND.
They can kick whoever off the show as they see fit.

Just enjoy the show or change the channel!
You don't have to watch it if all you're going to do is bitch about it!

Grassy knoll activity over at MSN. Phil's elimination video has been edited to remove his controversial comments and at least half of the Rockstar blogs (including Lukas' and Magni's) have been "sanitized" to eliminate any comments that weren't shiny and happy. Weird seeing censorship being tolerated in a rebellious genre like rock.

Are people up in arms because Phil is gone or because we are stuck with JanetFromAnotherPlanet for another week, the chick cannot sign, Phil out-sung her last night and she should have gone.

90 posts in 6 hours...is that a record...Remember, Dave, no such thing as BAD publicity...

love,
jezzi(pot-stirrer)

Yeah too bad this whole post, and comments, will come down in a matter of hours what with all the censorship being done on the official site vis a vis Phil's exit interview and the rocker's blogs. Gots to have all the players playing the same game dontcha know.

I hope someone copies all this for posterity.

I just wanna say I WANT MY SRL!!!!
You doing a show tonight, Dave?

Even Phil's July 24th blog has been changed to delete his comments about the songs they had to choose from AND his July 21st comments about liking the new Supernova songs. Phil clearly isn't there to make the changes.

Freefalling, the rockers' blogs aren't the rebellious genre of rock. It's the twisty genre of TV. Remember, the blogs are part of the Mark Burnett Productions machine. And besides... none of what was edited was all that important IMO. My guess? It's some TV producer with his tighty-whiteys in a bunch over nothing.

This really comes down to this....
Both Phil and Zgirl sucked. He can't sing, I just listened to his band's stuff and his voice is like a fingernail on a chalk board to me.
So which ever order they axed them, neither one will stand up there in the end. Lukas, Dilana and Magni are the only real serious singers up there in IMHO. Tommy loves Lukas, its so obvious when the flash to him every performance, he is grinning like a kid. Which is so cool. Jason cracks me up when he holds his ears everytime Jill sings. So she is next to go or not far behind. Dave i love your new work with Panic Channel!!!

Here's Phil's original comments from the July 21st blog before it was "sanitized"

"I’m finally excited about potentially singing for them. The first track that we heard way back didn’t really excite me, but it was only partial and when I heard the whole thing I liked it a lot more. The other tracks were real cool so hell fu**ing yeah Bitch!!"

This is part of what was removed from Lukas' blog: I’ve been chilling out and we are going to VOIVOD'S CD release party which is kind of cool, but strange. How many bands do these boy’s have? But whatever that’s their business. RISE ELECTRIC will always be.

JUKE CARTEL will happen was removed from Toby's

There is alot more that was removed. Rockband has alot of the old blogs (and some cute pics of Dave, Tommy and Phil, as well)

Can someone tell me the address to the blogs (old or new)? I'm intrigued...

I know very little, o.k. nothing, about music, however I am not tone deaf. I have only been watching since the 4th week, and I would have to say that there is a lot of incredible voices and a few not so incredible. Take Patrice, I personally don't think she is a possible front person for the band, but WOW that woman has a voice that can cross over to a lot of different genres.(which I hope she finds her niche (agent) that will take her there, I personally, would like to hear more) I think SN is looking not only for a voice but a particular persona that fits the music and the image the band wants to promote. So, where was I going with this? Oh yeah, while all players have talent, not all fit the SN niche. This is more than just a talent contest, this is a talent contest with a specific purpose. Who is in this to fit the mold, if these talented artists where to go to an audition, they would not lose sight of that purpose, but here on the multimedia machine, some have lost sight of why they are here. Best of luck to all, hopefully those that don't fit the SN niche will move on and be discovered, and then there are those that just don't do it for me vocally, but they have the SN image (Toby,Lukas) The female voice talent is pretty hot, Storm rocks and Dilana has the whole rocker image with a kick ass voice. The only male voice talent that gets me off is Magni. NOT only is he HOT, (and bald) but his voice is incredible. Peace for posterity baby!!

Hey Dave, High Five on your comments and a good ass pinchin too!!! Right on! Love the show..and the comment drama..heehee..*big snogs* M

Whoa...whoa...just read something that nobody has picked up on yet.

Join me on the grassy knoll folks.

If Dave and SN didn't know the results before the beginning of the elimination show last night, what would have prompted Dave Navarro to whip out a newspaper and read the interview Phil gave which caused him to get the boot?????

Are we to believe that Dave just happened to be carrying around that particular newspaper with that particular Phil interview???

I smell a fix.

'They want you to 'crush it', then offer up Time After Time - an awesome song, but you can't crush it. They want to be fresh and new, and yet their music so far sounds like Clash Lite. They say, "have you even ever seen our bands?" and yet, they arent' playing that kind of music, so why the heck should that be even relevent? '

I couldn't agree more. I have to wonder why they don't give them songs to choose from that reflect more accurately the type of music they want to play.

BTW- Storm's version of Anything, Anything was kick ass!!!!!!!!! I like her! Dilana is cool too!

This is very interesting reading the comments. Last summer, I knew nothing of this site, would have been cool to read the comments. I guess, as DN stated in a MP3 interview, everyone has a different interpretation of a song and I am sure of a singer. Tommy,Gilby, and Jason all favor a different type of music. They have to decide if this person will fit in with them. Phil didn't have the flash and balls necessary for a rock band. Drone-like. Kinda like Ryan,Dana,Josh,Zayra,they need a few Red Bulls I think. I mean KICK IT! I guess I have been to way too many KISS shows. I do not like Zayra, she does not know what metal is. Quiet song or not she's out. I am really enjoying hearing all these different songs and seeing my hero every Tue and Wed. Luv U DJ MoTH;) Anywho, great comments peeps. Happy Fri and weekend 67ers, Keep rokin :)

Hey, Roxie, here is the link for all the Rockstar contestant blogs:
http://rockstar2006supernova.spaces.msn.com/

But they've all been sanitized, unfortunately.

Maybe, now don't shoot me here since we're on the whole conspiracy kick, it's not Dave posting the comments but a really, really, really good PR person. Crazy? Maybe, but then, where does he find the time?? Twixt hot babes, like the quaint exchange between Brooke and him, his band, and the show. There ya go, setting the stage for more conspiracy theories.

Are the contestants allowed to give interviews while living at the mansion? I ask because of the interview Zayra gave over the phone to www.guidelive.com on July 10th.

LOL.

Check this out.

http://www.rockstargohome.com/phil-ritchie-rock-star-supernova-interview.php

Phil isn't even allowed to talk about the thing that played so heavy in his booting.

That's just whack.

Not allowed? Maybe Phil's finally getting smart and realizing he only made himself look bad shooting off his mouth.

Thanks for the interview link. Yeah, funny they wouldn't let him address the real issue. Still, I'm surprised they included a MySpace link:
http://www.myspace.com/lennex

Hey, what do you bet that the next performance show, there will be some predictable drama?

And it'll unfold like this: Tommy, Gilby, + Jason will exclaim how seriously committed they are to SuperNova, and that if any of the rockers doubt their commitment, well, then those rockers can just get up and leave right now!

Silence.

And probably some other shit, like: "Watch what you say because what comes around, goes around."

[All while Dave is creaming in the corner, loving how the drama + the buzz will increase ratings.]

^^^

Oh but wait, didn't you read Newsted's blog which you linked to above?

Priceless.

Here's a bit (dated today):

"And musical innovation is important. To have an understanding of our (Supernova’s) music but also of the future—to be contemporary and beyond. Somebody coming into this will be a little younger than we are, so they should bring the flavor of their generation into our music. That’s something I’m really looking for."

An understanding of their music? What the hell is he talking about? THEY don't even have an understanding of their music.

I got through about half these posts and I wanted to interject. I have to say, i'm half impressed with how passionate everyone is and yet, it's a little unsettling at the same time. It's a band, it's music and it's about expression and entertainment for PLEASURE! Yet, I see words like "boycott" being used because Jimmy pulled my hair on the playground. If that makes no sense, then you understood!! Are you kidding me. It's a reality TV show. If this is the one thing in the world that is going on that you are gonna make your political statement about. You might want to switch over to the local news channel next Tuesday at 9 pm. There are way more important things to get "boy-cotty" over. Sorry, I know people are passionate about their music, but come on!!!
Now, for my second 2 cents....
I'm not a musician by any means, I've never been in a band, lotsa my friends are, and I understand with an unsigned band the importance of focusing. but I just wanted to understand why some of us are having a problem with these partucular musicians "being in two bands at the same time". It's possible, right? Dave, do you know anyone who does it successfully? oh, yeah, you do!!! I mean, as known by the world, all three existing members of SN have had the rockstar experience, done the multi-million album sales thing. This is play time for them in all honesty. They can now do it cause they love it,and just for the fuck of it, and do whatever they want, Their lively-hood doesn't depend on it. They have busted their asses to get where they are and have the opportunity to spread their wings whenever and however they want. This is an experience of a lifetime for anyone and everyone involved. The second every single one of these "singers" was chosen to be on tv, it was all about exposure. They would be seen, no matter what. And the fact that they aren't gonna have to struggle with this particular band to get signed or noticed or booked or anything, it's all set. Not for nothing, if it were me competing, I would prepare myself for the fact that this might not work out as a long term gig. If it doesn't turn out the way they are hoping, SN will drop the idea as quick as they probably jumped at it. They don't have that much to lose if it doesn't work out. Hell for all we know, it might just be an already planned out life span, pre scheduled gigs and tv spots, and then that's it. nothing else. Mabey the RS is the actual money shot!!
I know I sound pesemistic (i have no idea how to spell that) but, anything is possible. I just appreciate it being something to watch every day that gives me the following means of giggles:
1. I get to see Dave twice a week
2. I get to make fun of people
3. See #1
4. I like music, and I like to see other people interperet songs I know
5. See #1
I hope i'm not pissing anyone off, but then again you can always boycott reading my posts!!! ha ha lighten up. there are so many things to get pissed about. I had to tell myself the same thing after I ranted about Patrice and the nerve she had to give Dave any lip the other night!
I love this place, the people in it and most of all the reason we are here.
Now ready, aim, fire......

I got through about half these posts and I wanted to interject. I have to say, i'm half impressed with how passionate everyone is and yet, it's a little unsettling at the same time. It's a band, it's music and it's about expression and entertainment for PLEASURE! Yet, I see words like "boycott" being used because Jimmy pulled my hair on the playground. If that makes no sense, then you understood!! Are you kidding me. It's a reality TV show. If this is the one thing in the world that is going on that you are gonna make your political statement about. You might want to switch over to the local news channel next Tuesday at 9 pm. There are way more important things to get "boy-cotty" over. Sorry, I know people are passionate about their music, but come on!!!
Now, for my second 2 cents....
I'm not a musician by any means, I've never been in a band, lotsa my friends are, and I understand with an unsigned band the importance of focusing. but I just wanted to understand why some of us are having a problem with these partucular musicians "being in two bands at the same time". It's possible, right? Dave, do you know anyone who does it successfully? oh, yeah, you do!!! I mean, as known by the world, all three existing members of SN have had the rockstar experience, done the multi-million album sales thing. This is play time for them in all honesty. They can now do it cause they love it,and just for the fuck of it, and do whatever they want, Their lively-hood doesn't depend on it. They have busted their asses to get where they are and have the opportunity to spread their wings whenever and however they want. This is an experience of a lifetime for anyone and everyone involved. The second every single one of these "singers" was chosen to be on tv, it was all about exposure. They would be seen, no matter what. And the fact that they aren't gonna have to struggle with this particular band to get signed or noticed or booked or anything, it's all set. Not for nothing, if it were me competing, I would prepare myself for the fact that this might not work out as a long term gig. If it doesn't turn out the way they are hoping, SN will drop the idea as quick as they probably jumped at it. They don't have that much to lose if it doesn't work out. Hell for all we know, it might just be an already planned out life span, pre scheduled gigs and tv spots, and then that's it. nothing else. Mabey the RS is the actual money shot!!
I know I sound pesemistic (i have no idea how to spell that) but, anything is possible. I just appreciate it being something to watch every day that gives me the following means of giggles:
1. I get to see Dave twice a week
2. I get to make fun of people
3. See #1
4. I like music, and I like to see other people interperet songs I know
5. See #1
I hope i'm not pissing anyone off, but then again you can always boycott reading my posts!!! ha ha lighten up. there are so many things to get pissed about. I had to tell myself the same thing after I ranted about Patrice and the nerve she had to give Dave any lip the other night!
I love this place, the people in it and most of all the reason we are here.
Now ready, aim, fire......

P.S. Mad props to SN! I appreciate all that you are, all that you can be and all that you will become!!!! Show me the money!!!!
(A little jerry McGuire spoof!) Seriously, I can't wait to see the final product!! I have nothing but respect for TL, JN, & GC!

Now i know you hate me for the double posts, sorry. it said it didn't post

Well something has to increase ratings cause they are not that good, so I guess false drama will work. Now if Lukas gets tossed for his comments in his blog, I am done with RS:Super-crybaby-Nova. Maybe next week Dana or Storm will brush up against Gilby and he will lose his shit completely, while Tommy asks Jill if she is wearing panties.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/kg-photography/199704476/

Check out the link Laney...Me thinks they are real. From the few times I have Met Storm, She is all about being honest, in your face, tell you EXACTLY what she thinks...so I don't think she would have them done.

I haven't been here for ages, though I'd like to add my 2 cents to this Supernova 'debate'.....

Zayra might not be right for the band, but despite the naysayers here, she CAN sing. She also had the balls to pick a fairly obscure song...by the Belgian band K's Choice....who are pretty much unknown in the US.

There are lots of famous singers out there who technically don't have very good voices, though their distinctive voices have made them famous...the list is too long to add here.

Having a technically 'great voice' might not even be enough, if you don't have a unique singing style and/or look etc.

Then, there are others who can belt out a song, yet have no REAL emotion, no soul...nothing. I'm hearing A LOT of that this year!

Of course, Zayra adds a humourous element to the proceedings, that's always fun, it's probably the main reason why she's still there.

While Dilana is probably the only truly original singer in the bunch ....through her diversity in the songs she picks and her general style & vibe....she also might not be quite right for this band.

I'm wondering, do the band even know what they want?? I'm seeing a 'Scott Weiland type' fronting Supernova.

IMHO, the majority of contestants this year are way below par.

This is the BEST....of what...over 20,000 people?? Unreal!

Excuse me if I have the exact number wrong, I'm not following this as closely as some are.

Lastly, there's way too many poseurs this year......remember, just dressing, posing, screeching and snarling like a 'rockstar' certainly doesn't make you one.

Over & out......

SweetMelis...

Fuckin' A-

(the A- is for spelling)

;)

Dave,

You got to be loving this shit!Wow this is just what the show needed.I suppose when your in week 4 and there are really only 2 contestants (Lukas and Dilana)you need to shake things up.I appreciate that.Sweet!

BTW,if the whole Panic Channel thing doesn't work out and if the INXS dudes get too old to tour maybe you and JD can hook up cause you 2 boys wer smokin' together on stage last year.

That is still the best performance of either season and you are both so pretty.You could just call the band Pretty.I'm down with that.

Dammit Melis;) Great thoughts sweets, let us just enjoy sexy eyes(DN) the tunes and ROCK ON!

This is totally out of context, but can somebody please email me regarding posting to the message boards. I've subscribed, got a user name etc. but it says I can't post to the boards. How long does the activation usually take? If anyone knows or can help me, please email me...

roxiejean1@yahoo.com

thx!

Yeah Dave...

In light of those comments, the choice certainly makes sense.

I knew nothing of Phil's remarks in that regard. It's not an easy thing to stay informed on each and every thing these people do and say, and if anyone knows, you do. Thanks for informing us.

lukasfan, just read in E.Weekly the numbers were pretty good, having a good day are you?????????

Maybe Phil deserved to go and maybe Supernova has every right to boot him based on that published interview. But I can't help but still be disturbed by how this whole thing went down.

To me, the episode looked more like an inquisition than a mere elimination. It seems like Phil's fate was pre-determined even before the show began, it really didn't matter how well or how bad he performed against Zayra and Patrice, the kid didn't stand a chance. It also didn't seem to matter how bad Zayra and Patrice performed, they weren't really going anywhere. At least not that night.

To me, what Dave and Supernova did also left a cloud of doubt on the results of the voting, the actual number of which they never show on TV anyway. Did Phil really made the bottom 3? Or did SN and the show's producers decided to put him there after reading that interview? I mean, if they were really offended by his remarks, then why not simply disqualify him before the show or even before the performance episode if they already read what he said then. Give us a bottom 3 where the basis of sending somebody home is how well he or she performed that night.

Excuse me for saying this but this just stinks to high heavens. To say that it leaves a bad taste in my mouth is an understatement. Even Dave's timing for bringing that up sucks. The crowd was chanting Phil's name and Dave pulls a stunt like that?

Kudos to Mr. Ritchie, I can understand your need to defend your son and his integrity.

As for Dave not writing his own blog, I don't believe he would trust anyone else to take it as seriously as he does.

Deleting posts, that sucks!!!!!!!!! What a bunch of phony BS. I wnat to know what Lukas is really thinking, not what CBS wants him to think!!!!!

Krazy, I don't think Gilby is a part of the good ole boys club. Unlike Tommy, I've never heard Gilby make a sexist remark to any of the female contestants.

I can't remember who posted about how could Dave know that Phil would be eliminated before the show was aired. They taped the show around 10am that day, so of course Dave would know the results before air time.

Dave, wow you have doubled the amount of people who come to 6767!! By the time you retire, you're gong to have a helluva novel to write. If you're not really the one writing this blog, I hope it's not someones grandmother sitting in a casino in Biloxi Mississippi!!! Ha Ha

For Phil being a monotone and lackluster performer and talking crap about a band he is auditioning for?? Consider all factors before you go into your conspiracy theory. I don't like Zayra either.. One of them had to go!

I respect Gilby for what he said and how he is. Class act!

Ok! Here's a suggestion for everyone:

1. Get up out of the chair
2. Interact with other living things under the roof you share
(pets, family, plants, etc)
3. Exercise
4. Go get a life for Christs'sake

Unbelievable the sheer amount of animosity here. Conspiracy theories, grass knolls, people looking to call others hypocrites at half a chance, so called self proclaimed pot-stirrers, what in the hell is wrong with you people? Is this what your miseable lives have been reduced to? Conspiracy theories about a TV show? You people need to get out of the house more. Seriously.

Et tu, Brute?

Dave, interesting post. Can't say I totally agree with you, but be that as it may...

What do you think of the fact, that your blog is the only place, connected to the show, that still has the details surrounding the article and it's relationship to the outcome.

All references of it have been more or less removed from msn(see major edits on rocker blogs, and edited version of Phils exit interview), and Phil has been now guarded about the whole thing in post press.

Somethings rotten in Denmark Dave. I am no grassy knoll theorist, but what the heck!!?!?!

Anyway, peace and love, I am enjoying the show...it's different than last year, but it is a different type of entertainment I guess;)

:) "d" We need to get vincent D'Onofrio on the case.

Case # 676725, why was Phil ousted?

I have to admit, the only reason I watch Rockstar is for you, Dave. And only three of the contestants are worth listening to. Though I don't write here, I read your blog faithfully. The reason I'm writing is for Phil's dad who left a comment here.

I may not have been rooting for your son. But your words touched me. You're obviously a man who really loves his son very much. For that, best wishes to Phil in his future. It's great that he has such a fantastic father who supports him in everything he does. A true rarity in some areas of this world. May he remeber to always treasure that.

I love you too, OldSchool...you love Dave almost as much as me...
love,
jezzi(self-proclaimed pot-stirrer)

PS,...I found time today to hug my child, put in a 14 hour day, walk the dog..and express an opinion..
I love Dave because I feel I can be honest, and that he will be honest back...
I don't need someone halfway across the continent speaking for him. NOBODY here is criticizing Dave, in fact, there was a post that actually praised him for NOT deleting or censoring the posts, which makes me believe that he respects our views, instead of relying on just selected minions that try to be his volunteer publicist.

Dave, once again, thank you for addressing my concerns, I LOVE the fact you had a quick and concise reply...that was enough for me...and whatever opinions I have about the show, do NOT, in any way, shape or form, affect, the esteem I hold you in...

love,
jezzi(remember that Seinfeld episode about the grassy knoll....back...and to the left)

If this was such a cut and dried eliminatation like some are suggesting, why has there been massive editing to rocker blogs and even Phil's exit interview to remove mention of the newspaper article, among other things? In his rockstargohome interview, it was clear that Phil wasn't even allowed to speak of it in public. Why is it such a big deal that the evidence of it has to be erased on MSN and elsewhere? It just seems weird and excessive.

one comment on this show that has been irking me since the beginning - why are they playing INXS songs for RS2? They should be using clips of the new SN songs. =P

and re: who should've been kicked and when - remember, they've got a schedule to keep, and can only boot one person at a time...albeit they haven't really booted the "worst of the week", etc...they'll all soon be hitting the road.i'd say more than half of these contestants aren't made to front a band like SN. dana could have a killer country singer career, and josh could have one helluva hootie-like career, and zayra...well, she has a distinctive voice, and i have to agree w/ DN - she could really get a solo career going, just not one fronting a rock band.there's my 2cents.

aloha! =)

dude, i would be offended and not interested in the guy at all if he was talking shit like that! i mean, i don't like zayra or whatever, but it's true. she's trying to mix it up. all i know is, i'm having a party when she gets booted.

Jesus people. Methinks some of you doth protest a little too much. The truth is Phil sucked ass, really badly! And for that matter so did Zayra. They both needed to go home.

But conspiracy theories and Dave the SN boys plotting against contestants. Jesus! It's a TELEVISION SHOW. It's meant to be entertaining and it's meant to garner all this attention is it not? I'm sure ratings are through the roof.

At the end of the day, Dave is right, he DOES have a JOB and some of these contestants sit and dribble about how they WANT to hear the harsh criticism because it makes them stronger. If you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen. So, why is it suddenly turn on Dave week? If you don't like it, don't come here and read.

Do you really think Dave is at home crying in his beer because people are slagging of his musical opinions? (opinions which he damn well has the kudo's to back up, the man is a musical legand is he not?) If you do, then you need to seek psychiatric help and quickly.

I do agree with what some people say about 'crushing it'. It's very hard to crush a song like Time After Time. As for Mr Ritchie, I'm a parent too, and I'd defend my child, but I'd be willing to admit that perhaps the experts were right and she didn't fit in with what SN need or want in a lead singer.

As for the twat who told Dave to concentrate on things at home, that's just a teeny bit childish don't you think? You may not like his musical opinions etc, but give the man the decency and respect of leaving his private life out of it.

The playground is THAT way and don't let the door hit you in the ass on the way out.

The song that the "rockers" listened to in the mansion that was supposed to be SuperNova's new sound sounds an awful lot like....

Gilby Clarke's Cure Me or Kill Me... could you ask him Dave?

Oh and seconded with the post about INXS song still fronting the RockStar Credits.

I agree... Dave... you sweet thang you, what woul it take to make you happy? ~very wicked grin~

As for this whole ''drama'' with Phil ect... Dude, SN will pick who they want, period. And other ppl have been in more than one band, and those bands have been sucessful. Some bands, the singers do solo albums, then go back to the band, why is having TWO bands any different? oui? Oui... ~smiles and disappears~

Dave . Why has Lukas's blog been edited? And mp3's pulled?

Are the guys in SN that insecure?
So let's recap:
It's fine for SN to pimp their stuff the nth degree but not okay for anyone else.
It's perfectly fine for the guys to be overtly sexual but not Jill.
Seems fair.

I think the Rockstar people need to have a think about what message the blog edits and censoring is having to the credibility of the show, and the Supernova guys have to think about what it does to THEIR credibility when shit like this happens.

As to last night's show, Im just watching last night's show after... uhh.. not torrenting it.... and haven't got to Phil's performance yet but...

Zayra butchered I'm not an Addict.

She fucking butchered it.

Not as much as I thought she would mind you, but seeing as I thought I'd have to put a screwdriver in my ears that's not saying much.

Ok, I saw phil's performance, and he deserved to go. God that was brutal. Even Zayra looked good after that. Still think the edits are leaving a potential stink over the whole thing though.

Oh come on you people stop whining about the editing there is a reason that this is a Mark Burnett production correct?

He tricked you last year into thinking Marty Casey and Jordis Unga had a shot at the gig but really I love Marty but his voice is shot in certain registers he doesn't sing particularily melodic.Mig Ayesa a sweet man child but hello look at him INXS had a hard time not laughing visibly while he was performing and in fact were caught doing so on camera.

Dave already told us that if this was his gig he would already have picked the singer.You know what it's the same singer SN will pick.Your job is to figure it out.Mark Burnett's job is to keep you watching and to stop you from figuring it out too soon.That's the show people.

Bwaaaahhhhh !

Hey, folks who think the voting is fixed: notice that the bottom three have been hit heavily the show before with criticism..fans are not going to vote to keep someone like Phil or Zayra if SN and Dave are ditching on them..then SN gets to pick who goes home..get over it..their band, their life, their show, their choice. No, YOU cannot control it..lighten up and enjoy it.

Re: blog edits...if you have your own blog and post something bitchy, it is not unusual to go back the next day and change it or delete it. Maybe pressure came from above, but no one can make anyone do anything they don't want to do..period..esp on your personal blog. So get over that, too. :P

How do you guys have time to follow all these blogs? Damn, I am goin to have to give up my blog and email just to keep up with this one.

"Knolling" up here means sex in the meadow- the weather up here is just right for that, if anyone wants to join me on the knoll. ;)

SweetMelis posts = YAY!!!
especially the respect to TL, JN and GC -
without them there would be no RS:SN!!!

changing channel:

Hey Itanja...

agree with you fully...

and I woke up thinking Scott Weiland would be perfect for this band...

changing channel:

RE: Tommy - ya gotta take his off colored comments with a grain of salt... it's his way of complimenting!!!

RE: Jill - grinding on someone is alot different than comments towards someone!!!

changing channel:

and who the fuck cares what was removed from the blogs...

cause I believe that all RS:SN competitors signed agreements with the show on what they can and cannot do RE: the show and the show has a right to do what they want in protecting the show's image!!!

changing channel:

and how the hell do people come up with conspiracy theories re: RS:SN show??? i think there might be some wingnuts posting on this blog!!!

RE: Phil - i think his performances alone especially his elimination performance warranted him being kicked off!!!

RE: Phil not being able to speak against RS:SN in
below interview. Why would RS:SN pay for bad press?
http://www.rockstargohome.com/phil-ritchie-rock-star-supernova-interview.php
Let Phil get his own interviews on his own merit and spout out whatever crap he wants to!!!

Dave, fantastic blog. Also thought you and Steve were very entertaining on XM 48 yesterday (Thursday). You guys should get a regular XM gig! Anyway, I've been watching (and blogging on) Rock Star Supernova and am now reading your blog. Anyway, I don't know why people are shocked Phil was booted. One he was in the bottom three, two he did not take advice and three he told the media that he was not that into Supernova's music. Any one of these items is more than sufficient grounds for kicking him off. I do, however, agree with all those who think Zayra should be kicked. She did a poor job on K's choice "Not an Addict" and moreover she does a poor job on all her songs. The guys really need to throw her off the show the next time she ends up in the bottom three.